In Portland Maine, a young woman named Amy goes out one evening with friends. At a bar she meets a stranger named Jeff. Jeff invites Amy to a house party. It sounds like fun and the two leave together. Amy is never seen again. Jeff comes forward, but detectives can't pin him to Amy's disappearance. With the trail growing cold, the lead investigator makes the unusual decision to consult a psychic he hears on the radio. Despite knowing next to nothing about the case, the psychic, Vicki Monroe, tells the investigator many things. She believes the woman is already dead. But what Monroe tells him next is most shocking. Amy, she says, is speaking to her from beyond the grave. Amy herself is telling Vicki the name of the man who killed her. The killer, she says, is a man named Jeff. For the lead investigator, the trail no longer seems so cold.